I had several foam noodles stored under the seats and I threw them in the water and we all jumped naked in the lake and washed cum and juices off our bodies. The girls grab-assed each other and then they ganged up on me. At one point, I had hands from all five of them on my cock and balls. I was fending them off pretty well until Molly went under the water and pushed her lips over my semi-erect cock. She quickly bobbed her head on and off and came to the surface coughing and sputtering. She looked at me and said, “That didn’t work out like I thought.” She came over and wrapped her arms around my neck and kissed me hard.
The others backed off and floated with the noodles between their legs. I could see that Divi was a little jealous but she didn’t say or do anything. Sophie pulled the end of her noodle to her face and yelled, “Hey Jack? This is the size of your cock isn’t it?” The other girls burst out laughing and simulated blow jobs with their noodles, which had five inch diameters. Under the water, Molly was pulling herself to my erection with her legs. I was holding on to her waist and then my cock slid between her thighs. She broke the kiss and set her nose on the end of mine looking down into the water. I dropped my hands from her waist to her hips and when she looked into my eyes and whispered, “Put it in me. Please?”
I used my feet to kick us to the opposite side of the boat from the others and pulled my cock back from her and used one hand to guide it into her. The moment that my glans pushed inside I knew that she was a virgin. I pulled my face back and whispered, “Are you sure? This is going to hurt.”
She smiled at me and said, “I know. I’ve heard. I want you to take my cherry rather than one of those idiots I was going to give it to.” I smiled and she smiled back but it was clear that she was anxious about the pain.
I whispered, “It’s best to do it hard and fast and get it over with. Okay?”
She smiled and said, “Kind of like pulling a band-aid off, huh?” I grinned at her as I thrust my hips up into her. She muffled her scream with a hand and after several second she grinned when she realized that I was buried deep in her pussy. I stopped and let her adjust. She mumbled, “Fuck that hurt. It’s not so bad now.” I held my position in her pussy until she pulled her hips back and pushed back on again. She grinned and did another cycle and grinned again. I let her take what she wanted.
Divi swam around to our side of the boat and grabbed onto my shoulder to hold herself up. She grinned at Molly and said, “The deed is done?” Molly grinned and nodded as she pushed herself on again.
Divi leaned in and kissed Molly and Molly returned the kiss. Molly said, “Thank you Divi. I had resolved to give up my cherry to one of those guys at “Makeout Lagoon.” You were right that Jack would be a way better choice. I’m so happy that it worked out that way.” Divi grinned and kissed Molly again and then she spun around and kissed me on the neck with arms around my neck.