“Brandon! Damn you! Fuck you! Oh God! Right there! Oh Yeah!” She arches her back, grabs my head with both hands and nearly suffocates me as her pussy explodes in orgasmic bliss. Her pussy gushes hot liquid honey while her body convulses in pure pleasure. I stay with her until her orgasm subsides, then pull my fingers from her still quivering hole and lick all around her wide lips.
“See, I told you,” Kylie says, stroking Lauren’s hair as she strives to catch her breath.
“You were right,” Lauren nods. “It was amazing!
“And the winner of the sexiest pussy…”
“I haven’t even caught my breath yet!” Lauren protests. “Give me a second.”
“Okay,” I smile. “I’ll go clean up.” I linger, watching my sister’s chest heave as she catches her breath.
“Go already,” she says, shooing me away.
Damn! I just ate my sister’s pussy! Instead of feeling ashamed, I find myself wishing we were alone. I splash water on my face and stare at myself in the mirror. Pervert!
“Are we ready now?” I ask my sister when I return from the bathroom. She just nods but returns my smile with that ‘just fucked’ glow all over her face.
“The sexiest pussy award goes to… drum roll, please… Kristina!” Her smile is absolutely radiant. “With your rose petal pussy lips, sweet, exotic scent and feathery blonde hair, you’re going to have guys lining up to serve your every need!”
“Thanks, Brandon,” Kristina says. “But not with these tits.” Fuck! I never thought she was so self-conscious about her tits.
“You’re wrong, Kristina,” I admonish her. “You’ve got great tits. I admit guys like cleavage but your nipples are the end all of nipples and your ass – don’t even get me started on your ass again, plus you have the sexiest pussy in the room. Wanna fuck?” I didn’t actually say that last part but I was thinking it. I would love to drive my hard cock into that tight, possibly unused pussy!
“If you say so,” she smiles.
“So who wins overall?” Alex asks. Good question.
“You are all sexy as hell. No guy could be disappointed with any of you.” I look around at the naked girls, bathing in their post orgasmic radiance. Shit. I just ate out four different girls and my cock is so hard I can barely think.
“The winner, Brandon?” Kylie prompts me.
“The sexiest girl in the room with best combination of attributes..” I pause and look at each of these naked beauties. “By a very narrow margin, mind you is… Lauren, my baby sister!” I point my finger at Lauren as I await the complaints from the other girls but they just start whooping and applauding my choice.
“What does the winner get?” Lauren asks, mischievously.
“You get to take care of that,” Kylie says, pointing to my erection.
“What?” Lauren responds incredulously. “Wait… no.”
“He’s been hard for nearly two hours, don’t you think he deserves some release after eating all this pussy?”
“Yes, but…” my sister stammers but Kylie cuts her off.
“You’re the one who said you could deep throat a real cock and wish one was here.”
“But he’s my brother,” Lauren retorts.
“Who just ate you your pussy!” Kristina jumps in to counter Lauren’s argument. “Seems to me you owe him one.”