She shifted again, spreading my legs a little and now kneeling between them. Jenna massaged my thighs for a while, then started focusing solely on the inside of my thighs only. Each time her hands dove deep inside them, she touched the tip of my hardening cock. Soon she had one hand massaging a thigh and one hand massaging part of my cock.
I raised my hips a little to give her more access. She was now able to caress my balls as well as stroke my cock completely. She paused to pour some oil into the crack of my ass, then resumed stroking. One hand rubbed the oil around my butthole. “Oh no, she’s not really going there,” I thought. But she did. She slid one, then two fingers in my anus. I surprised myself with a moan in response. She stroked my cock and “massaged my prostate” as I started moaning like her bitch.
I said “Ooohhh – I’m almost there!” and in one swift ninja-move she was on her back with her mouth below my dick. She kept stroking me to orgasm, and it all drained perfectly into her mouth.
After she had swallowed my jizz and moved back out from under me she said, “Didn’t want to waste any of that delicious spunk. Oh, and by the way, Ella told me you’d enjoy the fingers in the ass.”
Jenna then asked, “What would you like to try next? I’m open to almost anything.” I responded, maybe a little too eagerly, “I’ve never licked a shaved pussy before. I would love to taste that. I also have never fucked a girl in the ass before. Since you explored my ass a little, maybe you’ll let me explore yours.”
She laughed and said, “You’re in luck. I’m very proud of my smooth pussy, and my strongest orgasms come from a man or a woman’s tongue. Let me tell you a little secret – that woman in the other room licked me to one of my best orgasms ever, back when we were in college.”
“Good to know,” I said. I filed that juicy info away for later.
“Oh, and that other thing. I’m the only one of the sisters that enjoys anal sex. That’s a strong yes, too. Let’s get started. We have a lot to accomplish here.”
I had no idea I was going to be competing with my wife as I went down on her sister. As expected, her shaved pussy lips were a huge turn-on. My tongue found every smooth and wet fold. I traced her entire pussy with my tongue over and over. I was soon able to slide one, then two, then three fingers past both knuckles as I tongued her clit. My other hand massaged her perky nipples most of the time, too. For some reason, I was determined to “win”, and I kept at her until she had reached three different orgasms. My jaw was sore and locking up by the third. My tongue was numb.
Jenna said, “That was definitely the longest anyone has stayed down there for me. Three orgasms, are you kidding me! I hope you give my sister’s pussy the same attention, big boy. That tongue sure finds all the right places. I’m kind of glad you want to fuck my ass now. My pussy needs a break.”
Jenna handed me the lubricating oil and got on all fours. I moved behind her on the bed and poured way too much on her back and ass. She got a quick lower back and upper leg massage to help rub it all in. She sure didn’t complain. I lubed my entire shaft, spread oil on her butthole, then snuck an oiled finger in a few times to get her ready. I rubbed my cock along her pussy a couple of times and then inserted it slowly into her ass. It took a while to feed most of it in, but we did.