My cock was in Emily’s mouth and her sex was in mine. I felt the pleasure building and then I heard a pop as she pulled her mouth off my dick.
“Spin around,” she told me and I did. My cock nestled between her legs. The root resting right at her most precious place.
Emily kissed me hard, clearly she didn’t care about tasting herself. Actually, she told me she thought it was really hot and would find ways to “accidentally” get some of her pussy juice in her mouth.
Then she looked up at me with her big green eyes and said, “Stick it in me.”
I froze. I mean, I really did. Like my whole body just stopped responding.
“Come on Ryan,” Emily said, “I’m on fucking fire and my pussy needs that hard cock so bad. Put it in. Come on. Give your big sister what she needs.”
“Condoms,” I managed to croak out.
“What? Noooo. I want you inside me not some thing wrapped in latex. I trust you. I know you won’t put your stuff in me.”
But I argued her out of it. It just wasn’t a good idea. We were both smart enough to know that even if I didn’t cum in her, I could get my sister pregnant. And that really was too far. Even Emily agreed with me on that.
Condoms were the only option. Our parents wouldn’t let us go on dates, they certainly weren’t going to let Emily start taking the pill. My big sister talked about trying a convoluted story about an irregular period, but we both knew such a deception could take months. Neither of us was going to last that long.
“We can go too far,” I said, “If we’re not careful. If Mom and Dad find out, if anyone did, this would be over in a second.”
Emily nodded. I knew she didn’t want that. But she stayed sulky. I got, quite possibly, the most mundane, indifferent blowjob a sister ever gave her brother. I did my best to get Emily off, as well, but after a while we just gave up and went to bed.
So it was that four days after my sister and I had agreed that ‘no touching’ was a safe boundary for both of us, I slipped out and bought a box of condoms on the way home from high school. That night we were in front of the TV — Family Feud was on. I remember, because of all the dinging in the background.
We got naked right away. I started kissing her, moving my mouth to her pussy, but she just pushed me away. I swear she almost stuffed my stick inside her before I could put the condom on. It wasn’t easy. I fumbled it a few times.
I moved my cock around for a bit, trying to find the right spot. Then Emily reached down and guided me in, herself. Just like that, without saying a word, my sister and I gave each other our virginities.
Saying ‘just like that’ makes it sound simple, which of course it wasn’t. First I had to break through her barrier, which made her scream bloody murder. If we hadn’t proved how thick the walls in the house were before, we did then.
All that stimulation of sliding back and forth in my sister’s tightest place was too much for me and I came. So while my sister was howling in pain, I was rolling in pleasure. I pulled out and the condom was covered in blood, filled with my semen.
wpDiscuz