He sucked one of her nipples as he lined himself up. He nibbled her ear as he entered her holy place, promising her that he would give her a baby.
“You can try,” she told him, looking at me, staring into my eyes, “but Jimmy will be the father of my children – else I will die childless.”
It was the first time I had ever seen Lilith look sad. It was brief – little more than an instant. Her eyes quickly refilled with lust. But I knew I had seen it.
That perverse transparency evaporated the last of my resolve to keep myself from her.
I had seen her lusty looks bestowed on so many. I had watched her beguile and bewitch peers and adults, alike. The honesty of her expression in that moment was something that I was sure I was the first (and only) one to have witnessed.
“What did you say?” I asked her.
I stared into her eyes as Johnny continued to thrust into her – groaning and moaning. It was like watching a horny mutt humping a bitch in heat.
She was silent for far longer than I had ever heard her be before.
“I am waiting to have children until you are willing to be the father,” she told me.
“And if I refuse?”
“I will wait.”
“That’s why you only fuck them with protection?” I asked.
Her eyes shifted – for just a moment – to the young man who was obviously getting close to nutting inside of her. Then, she looked back at me.
“That’s part of it.”
“Part of it?”
“I want you to be my first,” she said.
A bark of laughter exploded from my lungs. “Your first?” I asked.
“The first skin to touch me, inside,” she clarified.
I thought of the many times I had jerked off. This school year, most of those times had been to images of Lilith’s body. In a way, it made sense, oddly. My cock had never touched the insides of a woman; her pussy had never been touched – skin to skin – with the sexual organ of a man. I nodded.
“Kiss him,” I told her.
I was trying to remember if I’d ever seen her kiss one of her lovers on the lips. She’d sucked their cocks and their balls. Her lips had teased their pricks, their taints, and their nipples – but had she kissed them?
“Is that an order?” she asked.
Suddenly, I decided that I didn’t want her doing this with anybody else.
“No,” I said. “Save those lips for me.”
“Gladly,” she purred. A smile curled the edges of her mouth.
My cock lurched in my shorts. Her eyes noticed. She licked her lips until they glistened and then worried her lower lip with her teeth.
She reached down and shoved a finger into Johnny’s ass. He screamed as his balls erupted and he buried himself inside of her to deliver his seed to the comforting care of the condom he unknowingly wore.
Lilith took his head in her hands, kissed his forehead, and laid his cheek against her breastbone, snuggling his spent form to her own. She looked into my eyes the whole time.
Johnny was panting. His eyes were closed. Lilith eased him to his side, sucked his penis clean, and rolled him back onto my bedcovers.
Having finished the show, she told me, “I am yours whenever you are ready, Jimmy.” She was looking into my eyes – just like she always did.