“Ohhhhhhh! Sara! Ohhh! God!” John moans as I release his cock and it stands straight up in his lap. With one knee on either side of him, I kneel on the couch, straddling his thighs. We lock eyes as I rise up on my knees and position my dripping pussy over his massive cock. Reaching between my legs, I rub his cockhead against my slick lips, lubricating him for the big event.
I’m scared, excited and thrilled. It’s my fantasy come true! My sister’s husband will take my virginity. Yes, it’s my first time! I’m sure John doesn’t know that and I’m not going to tell him. Leaning forward, I kiss him lightly on his lips as I spread my thighs as wide as I can. Easing down onto his cock, I feel my pussy stretching out to accommodate his girth.
“Ohhh! Fuck! Sara!” John moans, putting his hands on my shoulders and pushing me down onto him.
“Wait!” I breathe in his ear. “Take it slowly, John,” I warn him. “You’re kind of big.” I’m so scared but it’s the thrill of my life. I don’t ever want to regret it.
“Okay. Sorry, Sara,” he says, easing his ass back down onto the couch. “You just feel so incredible; so hot and tight,” he says, moving his hands from my shoulders to my head. Holding my face, he kisses my cheeks, my nose, and my lips before slipping his tongue into my mouth.
Turning and twisting, pushing down then easing up, I glide myself down onto his hard cock, until it hurts. Oh fuck! This is it. I can’t let him see my face. Pushing my tongue into his mouth, I raise my hips up until just the tip of his cock is inside my pussy. Bracing myself for the worst, I slam down onto his hard cock burying it completely inside of me in one excruciating plunge.
“Arrrrrggghghhhh!” I yell as the pain shots through my loins and I suck in a big gulp of air.
“Sara?” John says, jerking his head back to look at me. “Oh God, Sara!” The shock on his face is painful to see. “You weren’t… ohmygod!… Oh fuck!” he’s pushing me away.
“No!” I hiss, pushing myself back down on him. “It’s done! It’s what I wanted… what I’ve wanted for a long time!” I can taste my tears running into my mouth. “Don’t spoil it, John,” I plead. “Please don’t spoil it.” I settle onto his cock and pull him tightly against me, mashing my tits against his chest. “Just hold me a minute,” I beg.
“Sara,” he whispers as he brushes damp hair from my forehead. Running his hands over my shoulders and down my back, he pulls me against him. Gradually, I start a slow rocking motion with my hips.
“You should have told me,” he says.
“You wouldn’t have done it,” I smile, sitting up straight and rocking a little faster on his glorious cock! “Would you?” I ask as he fondles my tits and I look into his beautiful brown eyes.
“No, I guess I wouldn’t have,” he says, pinching my nipples and thrusting into me. And we’re actually fucking! The pain has subsided and the pleasure is incredible! I’m bouncing on my brother-in-laws massive cock and he’s twisting and pulling my hard nipples.
“Ohhhhh! God! John!” I moan as I the rhythm of our fucking increases and I’m riding him like he’s the wildest stallion in the world and I have to tame him. But he’ll never be tamed! I don’t want him tamed and I’m sure Jenny doesn’t either! A wild stallion for the two of us to share, I fantasize!