We spent the next four hours switching back and forth as I would fuck one of them to two or three orgasms and then switch to the other to give her the same treatment. Each of them begged me for my cum and I didn’t hold back, filling them over and over with my spunk. Amber was riding my cock as Evie lay beside us recovering when Amber looked down into my eyes and said, “Dale, would you please do me the honor and marry me!”
Evie and I both exclaimed “WHAT!”
“Think about it. We really do get along well, like you said and I know we have similar interests besides sex. And we are definitely compatible in the sack! Plus I love Eva dearly and would never deprive her of your incredible cock! You could fuck her any time you wanted to and nobody would be the wiser!”
“Sounds good to me,” Evie said.
“That’s a big step, especially for a LITTLE high school boy!” I said as both of them punched my arms.
“I didn’t say you needed to do it today, but after you get out of school would be nice. Just think about it.”
The subject was dropped but I knew all of us were thinking about it. Around 4:00 PM I was laying on my back with Evie riding my cock at a leisurely pace while Amber was riding my face as my tongue worked wonders on her clit. I heard a car door open and close and tensed at the thought our folks would be home early, but then heard it drive off and returned to my task at hand of getting both girls off at the same time.
Less than two minutes later both girls bodies stiffened as they cried out in unison speaking over each other, “Oh my god, I’m cummmmmingggg! Do it, oh fuck don’t stop…DON’T FUCKING STOP! Oh god it’s so good, cumming so hard!”
They froze when our mom shouted “EVA JANE PARKER! HOW COULD YOU? AND IN YOUR BROTHER’S ROOM!” She took some deep breaths while the girls blushed and looked at each other and then back at her. “I know you are both adults, girls, but if you must bring home a boytoy for the two of you, at least use your own room! Just because you hate Dale is no excuse to use his room!”
Evie tried to speak, “I don’t hate…” but mom cut her off angrily.
“Shut up! Everybody knows how you detest your brother! Now you two need to get off of Mr. Boytoy and send him home. Then Eva, we need to talk!”
“Mom, where’s dad?” Evie asked.
“I felt tired so I took a cab home. He’s trying to get some really nice items at the auction so he’ll be two or three hours more, why?”
Evie nodded to Amber who slowly lifted her leaking pussy off of my face and I said, “Hi mom, I’m home!” as mom gasped hard and fell back against the wall!
“Oh my god! This is impossible!” our mom said as she shook her head and looked at us again, sadly seeing the same sight each time she tried. “Dale, how could you! I mean with your…EVA GET OFF OF HIM THIS INSTANT! My god, Eva, that is INCEST!”
Mom was standing at the foot of my bed and had a perfect view of our joined sex when Evie very slowly lifted her ass into the air as my cock slid slowly out of her hot love box. When she was half way off of me our mom gasped softly. After another two inches mom softly said, “Oh my god,” and when Evie reached my tip Mom said in a much louder voice, “Oh fuck me, oh my god, Dale!”