“Don’t be mad at me, Susan. I only asked Wendy to be quiet so I’d have a chance to be with you, too, instead of Jasper’s stupid bet being over. I know that if I had to go back to being the one to make the first move, I never would, and I really wanted this with you before we graduated and I might never get another chance. Can you forgive me?”
“And now you want me to be quiet so you get a shot at Dani and Colleen, too?” she asked.
“Yes. Is that so wrong? More wrong than accepting a bet or bribe to take my virginity, something I was always willing, but dumb-fucked unable to do on my own? If I’d just been a normal guy, I bet I would have dated all four of you by now. I’m just trying to get caught up a little.”
She said, “A normal guy wouldn’t have made such a great study buddy, Kurt. So, I’m glad you’re not a normal guy, and could be such a good friend to me, instead. I can accept being your number two, and yes, I’ll keep quiet. On one condition.”
“And what would that be?”
“You can keep the money, but I want a couple more nights with you, after Danielle and Colleen are done with you, one before finals, and one before graduation,”
I could only chuckle, which made her glower at me. “What’s so funny?”
“Wendy asked for the exact same thing. Guess I’m going to be busy between now and Graduation.”
“Oh, she did, did she?” Wendy asked, before pulling her covers over us and snuggling in tight against me, and we soon fell asleep.
~~~~~
I awoke in the morning, when Wendy snuck into the room she shared with Susan to get some clothes, before an 8 AM class. Susan didn’t wake, and I blew Wendy a kiss, which got me a smile. I didn’t know whether Colleen or Danielle knew I was in Susan’s bed. I knew they also had 8 AM classes, so I waited until 8:05 to shake Susan awake so I could give her a proper goodbye, and snuck back to my own apartment.
And ran right into Tom and Dave, who were having cereal for breakfast.
“Where did you spend the night, Kurt?” Tom asked, grinning, clearly expecting any answer but the one I gave him.
“Fell asleep studying with Susan, and she let me sleep in her bed,” Well, it was partly true.
Tom and Dave exchanged the most transparent looks, and I had to force myself not to laugh or smile. As much as I appreciated their concern for me, it served them right for plotting behind my back.
I said, “Got to get ready for my 9:30 class,” and headed for the bathroom to grab a shower.
~~~~~
Colleen and Danielle both asked me to study with them Wednesday night, and I wondered how they were going to peel one of them off so the other could seduce me.
They could nearly have been twins, two brunettes with similarly short hair styles, petite figures both at 5’2″, the distinguishing difference being Colleen’s pixie nose, and a slight elvish look to her left ear, where there was apparently a quirk to the cartilage that made that ear look pointy.
They had started out Freshman year with Colleen as Wendy’s roommate, and Danielle as Susan’s, but they bonded over a history of being football cheerleaders at competing High Schools in our city. The girls swapped roommates the following year, and the four were in the same apartments Junior year and now.