Jane nodded and got up but Sofia said, “I want to do it down here with everyone around. I kind of get off on the idea of everybody watching me. Can I do that?”
Jane smiled and said, “You can do whatever you like. Let’s get you cleaned up and then we will come back down here.”
Anne decided to join Jane and Sofia upstairs. The others went back to their lovemaking while I watched. Before long Sofia was on her way back down with Jane and Anne. She walked up to me and kissed me deeply then turned and got down on her hands and knees. Jane got down behind her and began preparing Sofia’s ass with her tongue and fingers. When Jane had three fingers and plenty of lube in her she moved aside and said, “Make it wonderful!” as she lubed up my penis.
I kneeled down behind Sofia and took in how petite she was. While I was looking at Sofia’s cute ass, Jane took my cock and positioned me at Sofia’s anus. I began pushing in but Sofia was so tight I couldn’t make any headway. Jane bent over and began whispering to Sofia and kissing her cheek in an effort to get her to relax. After a bit, I began to slide in and managed to get my head past her sphincter. Sofia let out a low groan as I stopped to let her adjust. She was squeezing me very hard at first and then began to ease up. Jane continued to whisper and kiss Sofia and Anne kneeled down and began doing the same thing on the other side. I felt Sofia pushback against me and another inch slipped in. She was so hot and tight I was afraid I wouldn’t last very long.
Sofia pushed back again and again working me into her rectum. After several minutes, she had managed to get all of me into her. I waited for a few seconds and then pulled back until just my tip was in her. I squeezed a healthy amount of lube on my cock again and then slowly pushed my way back in all of the way. Sofia cried out “FUCK! THAT HURTS SO GOOD! FUCK ME SLOWLY, TONY!” I began with a very slow tempo savoring the sensations as I slid in and out of Sofia’s tight ass. After a little while Sofia began moving back against me as I moved forward causing our tempo to get a little quicker and causing me to bump into her ass cheeks. Sofia was groaning loudly as our pace continued to quicken. I saw Jane shoot her arm under Sofia to begin playing with her clitoris. Sofia screamed, “HOLY FUCK! FUCK MY ASS HARD, TONY! FUCK MY ASS!”
I was pounding Sofia pretty well as I felt my orgasm begin to tingle in my balls when all of a sudden Sofia’s climax hit her hard. She screamed out some unintelligible noises as she began shaking. Her orgasm pushed me over the edge as I began to ejaculate vast quantities of my goo into Sofia’s backdoor. Sofia collapsed to the mattress with me on top of her and still embedded in her ass. As I rolled over Sofia rolled with me keeping me inside her. After a while, Sofia said, “That was incredible! Thank you everybody for making that so special. Tony, I need you to do that to me two more times, that way I would have been truthful to the drug store clerk!” I started laughing making my cock move inside of Sofia. Finally, I shrunk enough that I fell out.