When I got back, Priya was humping on her hand pushed under her hips. I sat on the edge of the bed and scooped a generous portion of jelly onto my fingers. I pushed a large dollop of jelly onto her anus. She flinched from the cold jelly and then groaned hard as my index finger pushed the jelly inside as far as I could reach. I left my finger in her for a while to allow her to adjust. When I pulled out she shuddered hard with anticipation. I ran a thin coat all around her rosebud and then used the rest to lubricate my throbbing cock paying particular attention to the glans.
I got on the bed with my knees between her legs. I took my cock in my hand and dragged the glans between her butt-cheeks heading for her anus. She groaned as my cock bypassed her rosebud and pushed past her fingers into her pussy. I pushed all the way in, confident that I wouldn’t hurt her in this position. She whimpered as I fucked her that way for a minute or so. Then I pulled my cock out and ran my glans, lubricated by her natural lubricant and the petroleum jelly up to her anus.
Priya was already gasping for air. I put my glans to her rosebud and pushed firmly but slowly. Priya groaned hard and pushed back just as firmly. We spent at least a minute pushing together before my glans suddenly pushed past her tight sphincter. She groaned and I stopped until she signaled that she was ready to proceed. Three minutes later I was completely imbedded in her anus. Her sphincter pulsed tightly on my cock. I stopped and let her adjust again. Going slowly still, I pulled my cock back out again. Her sphincter muscle started to relax after a couple cycles and then the go-slow part was over and Priya took over the action.
When she pushed back hard on me, she let out a loud scream. I thought I was hurting her and stopped and began to pull back. Priya screamed, “Fuck no. Don’t you dare stop? Go. Fuck. Go.” I did as instructed and began pummeling her anus in full length glans to balls strokes. Jesus her ass was tight. I wasn’t going to last long. Fortunately, she didn’t last long either. Her fingers were working her pussy and clitoris and she screamed all the way into her orgasm. She didn’t have an anal orgasm like Anna had, but her vaginal orgasm was violent. She turned to look back at me pummeling her ass. Her eyes were bugged wide and her mouth was open in a long groan that ended with her holding her breath. If I didn’t know better, I’d have sworn she was in agony.
I was gasping from my physical efforts and then, there it was. My orgasm crushed me. Cum streamed deep into Priya’s bowels. She felt it too and she sucked in a huge breath of air and let her head drop to the bed. I could feel her vaginal clenches even though I was buried in her ass.
Priya let her hips fall heavily on the pillow pulling my cock from her bowels. I pulled back and extricated my cock from her anus. We both lay in a heap urgently gasping for air. When we recovered, Priya spoke into the mattress that surrounded her face, “I remember now what I was missing. She rolled on her side and said, “Jack. Your cock is perfect for anal intercourse. I don’t want to miss this again.”