She kissed me, before I could ask her whether her own flavor bothered her. She pulled back, and looked me in the eyes and asked, “That was really your first time licking pussy?”
I nodded, and asked, “Did… did I do good?”
“Mmmmm, yeah,” she answered. She reached down, and grabbed my dick. “Now for the main event. Are you ready to give me your virginity? I’m on the pill, so don’t worry about a condom.”
“Gawd, yes.” I momentarily felt shame at lying to her, but I couldn’t deny wanting her badly.
“I want to be on top,” she said. “I’ve been told I’m a bit small inside, so I like to control how deep a guy goes the first few times we’re together.” I couldn’t imagine my 6″ dick being too big for her, but she knew her own body best.
“You think… you think I’ll say no?” I got flat on my back, as Susan straddled me. Her hair surrounded my face, as she reached between us to take my cock in hand, and line me up.
She was so much tighter than Wendy! But all of the extra juiciness from my saliva and her own excretions made it fairly easy for me to slide inside, and soon she was pressed against my pubes. She kissed me again, trading tongues, and I supported her upper body by holding onto her breasts, and playing with her nipples, as she began rising and falling onto my cock.
“You can thrust your hips up into me, too,” she suggested. I’d been holding off on doing that, not wanting to seem too experienced, but was soon slamming up into her on each of her downstrokes. I felt her start to shake again, amazed that she’d come again so soon. I was just beginning to feel the beginnings of my orgasm.
“Oh, you’re the perfect length for me,” she said, when she settled down. “Why did we wait so long to do this, again?”
“I was too scared to make a move?” I suggested. “I didn’t know you wanted – ” She cut me off with another kiss.
“I want,” she said. “I want you, to fuck the hell out of me right now.”
I did my best, thrusting into her faster and faster, squeezing her nipples, as we both went into oxygen debt, panting like crazy. Just as I felt myself start to cum, I pulled both of her nipples away from her chest, and squeezed them, probably too hard, and she screamed, but she also came once more, as I shot stream after stream of cum into her.
Gasping for breath, we held each other, as she lay atop me, her thick, curly hair all around us. I ran my hands around her back, as she continued having little shudders from the contact, and my cock slipped out of her.
Confession time. “So, about Wendy?” I began.
“Yeah? About why you turned her down?”
“Not exactly,” I admitted. “It’s about how I didn’t turn her down, but asked her to say I did. And why I’m going to ask you to do the same, for a little while longer. I can even offer $150 as incentive.” I’d taken $300 out at the ATM, thinking I’d need $100 for each of the first three girls to buy their silence until I got to the fourth, but since Wendy had passed on it, I could split it up two ways instead of three.
“You mean, I wasn’t your first after all?” she asked, a little anger to her voice.