They started laughing. “What’s so funny?” I asked.
Colleen pinched my earlobe, then said, “That wasn’t the real beginning, Kurt, and you were meant to hear what you did. We were waiting until we saw you walking up the path, before we all went into our act.”
“Hunh?”
She said, “This was all Wendy’s idea, from the beginning, to take you to bed as a thank you for helping her so much these last four years. She’s the one who wanted to make sure you didn’t leave college a virgin, so she arranged the whole thing. From your roommates suggesting that you get a prostitute, knowing you’d say no, to letting you overhear about the fake bet. She thought that if she tried to approach you normally, that you’d get scared off. But if you thought it was all a secret plan to get you laid arranged by your roommates, you’d have some time to adjust to the idea, and let her take the lead. The whole idea was for her to win the bet. And it worked, too, didn’t it? Of course, she didn’t expect you to then want all of us, but she realized when you asked her to be quiet about it that we all had just as much to thank you for as she did, if not more. You kept me from failing two courses that I know of, and Danielle another, not just getting me to a D, but to a B and C. Susan has wanted you from the first day we met you as Freshmen, but she’s a lot more like you than you realize, unable to take the initiative with a guy. She’s better when she’s pursued, but you were always the one she wanted to do it, and you didn’t.”
“I wish I could have…” I said.
“It’s okay, Kurt, we love you anyway,” she said, tousling my hair.
Colleen leaned away from me as Danielle picked up the thread, “So, when Wendy told us that you were expecting us all to make our move with you, it took us each only ten seconds to agree to it. We let Susan go next, and I’ll tell you it was only finding out from Wendy that you wanted her too that let her play her part. She would have been too scared, otherwise. She also had a hard time pretending to be mad at you when you revealed that you’d had sex with Wendy first, since she already knew it. Colleen and I decided to do you together since we couldn’t decide between us who should go actually go last, and thought it might be easier to get you to go along with a threesome if you had Wendy and Susan before us. Besides, that let us be another first for you, your first threesome. Susan got to be the first pussy you licked, so I think it worked out well for all of us.”
At that moment, the door to their bedroom opened. In walked Wendy and Susan, in rather sheer nightgowns, and they sat down on the other bed. “Hey, boyfriend,” Wendy said. “Colleen sent us the all clear.”
Colleen waved the cell phone that had apparently been on the window sill next to the bed.
“Are you mad at us? At me?” Wendy asked, looking scared for my answer.
“Why would you think that?” I reassured her, pushing myself up on one elbow so I could see over Danielle. Somehow, being naked actually helped me keep my guard down. “These last few nights have… have fulfilled every fantasy I ever had about the four of you since we first met, but could never make come true on my own. If I had graduated and only made love with one of you, it still would have been more than I expected to happen. Somehow the four of you agree amongst yourselves to share me for a few days while letting me think it was somehow all my idea, and I’m supposed to be mad?”