Bill pressed the head of his well-lubricated cock to my anus and held it there for a moment. He pushed a little harder, then backed off. Each time he pushed I felt the head go in slightly. A minute later his cock head was in me.
“That’s the hardest part. You doing ok?” he asked as he held the head just inside my butt.
“Yeah, it feels really tight but doesn’t hurt. Why are you doing this? I thought you liked girls?”
“Oh, I do. But every so often I get the urge to play with a guy. When I saw you with that tight swim suit and sexy body I just knew I had to have you. I heard from Joyce that Sue fucked you so I came in to check that you were ok. I couldn’t help myself. You have the sexiest butt I have ever fucked.”
Bill continued to press his cock into me. Another minute and it was inside.
“I’m in. You took it all. Congratulations. Not every guy can, especially the first time. Now I’m going to fuck you. And fill your ass with my cum.”
I was on my stomach with my boss on top of me, his cock in my ass. All sorts of thoughts went through my head. Was he making me gay? It felt good. Did that mean I already was gay? How long would he continue to fuck me? Would I feel his cum in my ass? Monday, how could I face him and the other guys?
Bill reached under me and playing with my cock. Even though I had already cum twice in the last few hours it quickly got hard.
“Damn, John. That’s some cock you got. As hard as it is you must like me fucking you, huh?”
“Yes, it feels pretty good,” I had to admit.
“Get ready, I’m going to fill you with my cum,” as he shoved his cock fully in my ass. I felt it twitch several times. A moment later I spurted into his hand.
“It’s late. Stay the night. You can use this bedroom. In the morning we can fuck again, ok?”
**********
I awoke to the smell of coffee. I was still nude and my clothes were somewhere else. What the hell, Bill’s already seen all of me. I walked into the kitchen. He was standing at counter pouring himself a cup. He was nude.
“Ready for some?
“You had quite a day yesterday. Joyce told me Sue sucked your cock and then fucked you. Then I fucked you in the ass. She said you were a virgin. Not any more, huh?”
“No, that’s for sure. I liked what she and I did. It was exciting. But I have real mixed feelings about you and me. I’m not gay, and don’t want to be. You took advantage of my drinking too much.”
“John, admit it. You liked my cock in your ass. You said so. You came while I was fucking you. Look, I’m not gay. I have several girl friends that I regularly fuck. I also fuck them in the ass. Their asses feel the same as yours. Except you have a sexier ass!”
Bill reached out and took hold of my limp cock.
“That’s quite a specimen you got. I’ll bet Sue was bowlegged after she fucked you.”
He fondled my cock and stroked it as it started to erect.
“I would let you fuck me but your cock would tear me apart. Sorry partner. Here, put your hand on mine. I’m only two-thirds your size but perfect for ass fucking. Don’t you agree?”
I tentatively stroked his cock as he did mine.