Mae’s moans continued, and she didn’t show any signs of pain. Unfortunately he couldn’t say the same for himself; he needed release. Feeling how tight her hole was around his finger, he knew he wouldn’t last long inside her.
Mae seemed more relaxed, and Logan was having too much fun toying with her hole, but he knew she was ready to go. He withdrew his finger, leaving a small gaping eye. He ran his cock through her pussy lips, coating it in her fluid. Trailing the now glistening, pulsating flesh up her ass, he poked her. Her wrinkled hole responded, spreading and sucking in air. He pushed forward, resting his cock against her it. He removed his hands, letting his cock sit there, then gripped her ass cheeks and spread them apart.
“Ready?”
“Yes.” She nodded, closing her eyes.
He edged forward. Her hole resisted but it was no match for the weight behind his hips, as the tip of his cock buried inside her.
“Haaa – aaaaaaaah!” Mae yelled out, but it wasn’t the pained screams he’d heard before, he knew it was a good pain. He knew her being relaxed, made all the difference.
“Is it in?” Mae asked through ragged breaths.
“The hardest part is over.” He said. They stayed like that for the moment, her hole sucking on his tip, as he traced his hands over ass and hips. Logan knew that if he made any sudden movements, he would come, and he wasn’t finished with his sister yet. He reached his hands up her back now, massaging her exhausted muscles. “Play with your clit.” He said, and she obeyed. His hands came back to her hips, and holding her steady, he pushed an inch inside her.
“Oh god that feels so good. It hurts but it feels so much better than that plug,” she said. Logan felt her muscles relax even further, knowing she no longer anticipated the worst.
Logan smiled, admiring the sight of his cock disappearing into his sister’s peach. Pushing another inch further caused her to whimper this time. “You ok?”
“Yes. Keep going.” Mae’s jaw clenched.
He stroked further this time, opening an untouched area of her body. “Oooooh. Fuck. Fuck, wait!” She clenched the sheets and pushed a hand against her brother’s thigh. He stopped, and started rubbing her body again.
“You’re all good girl.” Patting her rump like a mare’s. “Only a few more inches and the pain should be over. You alright?”
Mae only nodded in response, her eyes squeezed shut. Logan rocked forward again, this time he went all the way until the base of his cock was lost inside her. “Aieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!” Mae squealed and threw herself forward, now flattened on the bed with her legs hanging off the edge. Her breaths were short and sharp. Logan noticed the anguish on his sister’s face as she tried hard to compose herself.
He stayed in her though, his feet were planted firm on the carpet and he had her hips pinned down. He pulled his cock out, and drove it forward again.
“Aaaaaaaah -haaaaaah!”
This time they both cried out together. The tightness was overwhelming for Logan. Despite his worldly knowledge of women and the female body, he had never experienced anything as strangling tight as his little sister’s virgin ass. He moved in and out with more ease now, picking up a steady rhythm. “How does it feel?” He asked.