He started pulling out again, but she grabbed him with her legs and thrust him entirely balls deep again. At that point I lost it.
I finally shouted “THAT’S AGAINST OUR RULES!!” He quickly pulled his penis out and looked back at me horrified, while she looked over at me and dismissively said “it’s okay… he was just trying me out. I respect our rules. It’s not like he was about to cum or anything” and rolled her eyes.
His dick was so hard, and his balls were pulled super-tight against his body, which I know means he’s really turned on and probably close to orgasm with enough stimulation. So in the heat of the moment, I did something I will regret for the rest of my life.
Instead of kicking him out there and confronting my wife about her transgression, I for some reason said “okay… but let me get a condom first.” I quickly darted back out of our bedroom and went to the bathroom where I had a stash of condoms from several years ago before she went on birth control. They weren’t in the drawer I looked in initially, so I had to find them in the back of our bathroom pantry/cabinet. As I was looking for them, I heard her start breathing heavily and moaning a little bit. I hopefully assumed he was going down on her, and yet at the same time, my penis was going soft again. I wanted to go back in there hard, so before turning the corner to go back into the bedroom, I started jerking myself to get hard again.
I then heard him start to moan breathily and grunt. My stomach dropped when I realized he may not have been just going down on her. I immediately went around the corner and saw him with his almost orgasming cock deep inside my wife, BALLS deep. He was doing these short strokes, but again, with his dick head deep inside my wife, which meant like 80-100% of his penis was deep inside her, and his head probably right against her cervix.
I exclaimed “what the FUCK! I said I was going to grab a condom!” I don’t know how the fuck she didn’t know I meant get a condom for HIM to wear, because she says “OH! FOR HIM!”
She kept writhing around in ecstasy, throwing her head back in pleasure. As she did this, she was fondling his balls and taunting him “yeah, fill me!” He turned around and looked at me and goes “oh shit! Sorry! It’s too late! I’m cumming!” and at that moment, I could see the orgasm explode within his head. His whole body tightened up.
My stomach dropped and panic was setting in, as I realized he was probably ejaculating directly onto my wife’s fertile cervix. And what fucking PISSES me off is that he didn’t pull out right away! He knew she was fertile!
I could see his dick and balls begin pulsing like three or four times as he shot his milky jets of semen all over the inside of my wife’s fertile vagina. He then withdrew his already ejaculating penis which squirted a big load right on her open vaginal hole, up onto her vulva and eventually more on her belly – but only a few drops, confirming that the majority of his load was deposited within my wife. Within her sacred sperm sleeve, to which only I had the right to access!